59% of Hiring Managers Suspect AI Résumé Fraud; Reference Checks Lag
59% of hiring managers suspect AI résumé misrepresentation; only 19% trust their process to catch fraud. Standardized reference checks are the fix, HR Daily Advisor reports.

Daniel Okafor
· 4 min read
Fifty-nine percent of hiring managers say they have suspected a candidate of using AI to misrepresent themselves during the hiring process, according to a 2025 Checkr survey of 3,000 hiring managers. Only 19% said they are extremely confident their current process would catch a fraudulent applicant.
Those numbers land on an HR process that has barely changed in decades: the reference check. Candidates choose their own references, questions stay surface-level, and former employers—worried about liability—default to vague positivity. The result is a screening step that rarely alters a hiring decision, even as AI makes it easier than ever for candidates to dress up a résumé beyond what they can back up. A reference, someone who has actually worked alongside the candidate, remains one of the few checks that is hard to fake.
The financial stakes are concrete. SHRM's most recent recruiting benchmark puts the average cost of a non-executive hire at roughly $5,500 and an executive hire at nearly $36,000. A reference check is among the cheapest tools an employer has to avoid paying that cost twice. Most organizations simply are not using it well, argues Marti Carr, president of Digital Marketing Recruiters, writing in HR Daily Advisor.
Why the reference check is a leadership problem
For years, the advice pointed at the person making the call: ask sharper questions, listen closer, don't take the easy answer at face value. Carr's verdict is blunter. Ask 10 hiring managers at the same company how they run a reference check, and you will get 10 different approaches—different questions, different follow-ups, different ideas of what is worth recording afterward.
Her prescription is to build the parts of the process that do not yet exist:
- Standardize the question set. When every hiring manager improvises, the process is inconsistent by definition—and a source of exposure if a hiring decision gets challenged. Treat the question set like the assessment tool it actually is.
- Train hiring managers to sit in the silence. A pause on a reference call is data. Most hiring managers are trained to fill silence, not sit in it; a short training module fixes this faster than you would think.
- Write it down. A few lines of notes after every call—what was asked, what was said, what gave the caller pause—protects the organization if a decision is questioned later.
Which questions actually work?
Research on reference check validity, cited by Carr, found that fewer than 1% of references ever rate a candidate as below average. Judgment calls such as "Is this person a strong leader?" invite a compliment. Requests for specific memory are harder to fake on the spot. Two questions belong in the standard set, Carr writes:
1. What advice would you give this person's next manager?
It is a smaller, stranger question than references expect, and that is the point. It asks the reference to be useful rather than complimentary—and that is usually where a real management quirk or growth area surfaces. A question about strengths never gets there.
2. What is a specific example of a time this person had to deliver hard feedback, own a mistake, or navigate a disagreement?
This reveals how someone behaves when something goes wrong, which the glowing first minutes of a call rarely expose. It also gives HR something concrete to compare against what the candidate said in the interview. The stakes are measurable: employees already spend an average of 2.8 hours a week dealing with workplace conflict, per the CPP Global Human Capital Report. A screening process that skips this question risks adding to that number.
Same call, better outcome
A better reference check does not take longer than a bad one. The same 15-minute call produces very different information depending on whether a standard exists behind it. What changes the outcome is whether HR treats the step like any other part of a defensible hiring process—standardized, trained and documented, no matter who makes the call that day.
With AI making it easier for candidates to dress up what they have actually done, the reference check may be one of the last steps in hiring that still depends on a real person answering a real question. The employers that standardize it now will be the ones still trusting their hires later.
Original: checkr.com
More from Daniel Okafor
Show full bio
Senior reporter covering technology and product news in Recruiting and talent acquisition, learning and development at HR Briefing.
283 articles