HR Briefing

Talent Acquisition

62% of Managers Credit Results for Leadership — So Why Do Top Performers Miss Promotions?

A 2026 survey of 500 US managers and a coaching case show why strong performance reviews don't produce promotions — and what HR should measure instead of output.

Why IT leaders who hit every target still get passed over for promotion
Why IT leaders who hit every target still get passed over for promotionAI-generated

Daniel Okafor

· 4 min read

A 2026 Enhancv survey of 500 US managers found 62% credited performance and results as the biggest factor in reaching leadership — yet only 6% named education, even as 65% called their own degree and credentials essential or very important in landing their current role. The contradiction sits at the center of a familiar people-process failure: high-performing IT leaders receive glowing reviews and still lose the promotion.

The piece, written by an executive coach who has coached more than 1,000 technology professionals one-on-one, argues the disconnect is structural. The performance review measures the job the leader has. The promotion decision asks whether the people above them can already picture this person one level up — a job they do not yet hold.

What does the review actually measure?

The coach opens with a VP of engineering client who met every target, received a review full of positive feedback, and one piece of criticism so vague she could not act on it. She was then passed over for the CTO role she had worked toward. When she asked why, she received a list of reasons — some she agreed with, some she did not — and nothing that told her what to do differently.

CIO.com has previously covered why VPs and IT directors with strong delivery records keep missing the CIO chair. The coach locates the problem earlier: the first time a well-reviewed IT leader gets passed over and cannot get a straight answer.

Ranjith Raghunath, CEO of CX Data Labs and a former leader at Amazon, GSK and Samsung Electronics America, described one of the hardest conversations of his GSK tenure: declining to promote his IT services coordinator to head of IT. The coordinator excelled at running support, resolving tickets, training employees and handling the thousands of small tasks that keep laptops and platforms working. The head-of-IT job demanded a higher-level, systemic thinker. Raghunath hired externally — the hire worked out — partly because he could not replace the coordinator's skill set or team rapport.

Raghunath also owned his own failure: he did not communicate clearly, and the candidate left feeling let down, convinced he was a perfect fit for a role he was not equipped for.

Why credentials and hours rarely close the gap

Volen Vulkov, Enhancv's co-founder, said strong people who get passed over usually respond by doing more of what got them noticed.

"More hours, more projects, another certificate. Our data says that's rarely what's missing. Almost nobody credited their credentials for their promotion," he said. "The people deciding are asking a different question: is this person already making the calls the next role needs? So, look at the decisions your manager makes that you don't. Then ask to take a few of them on."

The pattern the coach sees matches that advice: promoted IT leaders are already doing pieces of the next job before anyone hands it over. Passed-over leaders are doing the current job extremely well and waiting to be noticed.

Can the work speak for itself?

No. The coach's client assumed her record justified the CTO seat. He pushed back. The executive who had hired and championed her had left; her new boss knew far less of her history and saw her as a strong VP, not a C-suite leader. That perception — not her results — decided the outcome.

A colleague later transferred onto her team and admitted not knowing what the team did. Her team owned the platform the rest of the company was built on, while the other team's features depended on her work — a dependency invisible to the observer. If someone reporting to her could not describe the team's contribution, the executives deciding promotions certainly could not.

Senior roles differ from engineering ones, where the code ships or it doesn't. Decision makers see a fraction of the work and fill in the rest from what they hear.

What HR and talent leaders should take from it

The coach's prescription, when a client is passed over, is deliberately not more output:

  • A mini 360-degree review (a short, informal feedback loop with a boss and peers): the client learned colleagues could not always follow how she reached conclusions, so her decisions looked like skipped steps from the outside.
  • An internal PR campaign: treating executives as key stakeholders — more updates on what the team built and why, more positive feedback to peers, internal engineering sessions on platform direction, an all-hands presentation, and external speaking engagements so her name attached to the function.

The questions and tactics shift with the situation. The goal does not: the client stops producing more and starts making existing work visible to the people who decide.

The client remains at her company and on the path to the CTO role. She no longer assumes the review will make her case; she makes it herself. For HR teams calibrating promotion criteria, the lesson is that promotion rarely goes to the leader who did the most work — it goes to the one decision makers can already picture in the job, a signal talent processes should be measuring explicitly rather than leaving to informal perception.

Source: cio.com

Share this article:

More from Daniel Okafor

Daniel Okafor

Show full bio

Senior reporter covering technology and product news in Recruiting and talent acquisition, learning and development at HR Briefing.

295 articles

© 2026 HR Briefing. All rights reserved.