Job seekers turn to odd résumé tactics as application volume rises

Nathan Brooks
· 2 min read
Only 3.2% of applications reach a first interview, according to a 2026 Greenhouse analysis that found companies receive an average of 194 applications per hire.
The figures sharpen a hiring problem: employers face crowded, AI-assisted pools and must distinguish evidence from presentation. HR teams must screen consistently, structure interviews and decide whether an unusual detail deserves follow-up rather than automatic credit.
Why are candidates breaking the template?
Amanda McDormand, 43, had a few months of severance left when she began experimenting with applications. The New Hampshire-based senior leader had been laid off from Comcast in December, and auto-rejections filled her inbox. She felt she had little to lose.
In 2019, McDormand had turned down offers while exploring opportunities. This time, LinkedIn posts about job seekers sending hundreds of applications without replies over years-long searches left her unprepared for auto-rejections.
She tried an “I am not AI” letter and golf references for a manager who liked golf. Those experiments produced more callbacks.
Her first major win came through a Taylor Swift-themed cover letter. It produced a fractional role before her current full-time position. She invoked Olivia Pope, Ray Donovan and Taylor Swift:
“This isn’t a job application—it’s an idea, and I’ll get straight to it. I’m a corporate fixer. If you’ve watched Scandal, think Olivia Pope. If you’re more of a Ray Donovan person, that works too. And if you’re into music, I like to consider myself the Taylor Swift of business.”
She said she was “identifying the blank space” in an organization. She warned the employer they had “seen this film before, and it’s time to change the ending,” then closed, “This could be our era, just say ‘yes.’”
What changed when AI entered the résumé?
Recruiters report renewed résumé interest sections with odd details and candid statements. Some candidates add fun-fact infographics. Others insert punctuation or spelling errors to show a person wrote the application.
Carly Martinetti, cofounder of the PR and AI visibility firm Notably, recalled a seeker writing in a LinkedIn outreach, “I’ve been an in-house girly my whole career.” She called it “totally not something AI would say” and down-to-earth.
- Entries shared by recruiters and candidates included “buffalo chicken wraps,” “Suits,” “vampire and Robert Pattinson movies,” “clowning,” “mermaiding,” “lucid dreaming,” “love of french fries,” “superhero,” and “movie theme dinner party thrower.”
Ladders’ recent survey data found that over 84% of job seekers use AI to write or edit résumés. It also found that 76% of 237 surveyed seekers had taken at least one deliberate step to sound less like AI.
Before AI, Ladders founder and CEO Marc Cenedella “rarely saw people adding personal anecdotes to their résumés. It was almost a faux pas.” He now hears a different question from
Source: feeds.businessinsider.com
More from Nathan Brooks
Show full bio
News editor covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in Recruiting and talent acquisition, learning and development at HR Briefing.
270 articles