HR Briefing

Employee Wellbeing

SNL’s ‘Sister’ Skit Highlights the Gender Gap in Elder Care

Women account for 55% of the 38 million unpaid elder care providers in the U.S., as SNL’s viral “Sister” skit highlights the care gap’s workforce and retirement costs.

SNL's 'Sister' sketch captures the hidden burden of caring for aging parents
SNL's 'Sister' sketch captures the hidden burden of caring for aging parentssabinevanerp / pixabay

Nathan Brooks

· 5 min read

By Nathan Brooks

Women represented 55% of the 38 million unpaid elder care providers in the United States, based on 2023 and 2024 Bureau of Labor Statistics data. The Business Insider report announces no employer duty or compliance deadline.

Its people-process relevance is concrete: caregiving can drive reduced hours or job exits, cutting current salary and benefits while reducing opportunities to save for retirement and build future Social Security benefits.

What did the SNL sketch make visible?

Comedian and host John Mulaney featured in this weekend’s dark SNL sketch, “Sister,” a parody advertisement. Actor Jane Wickline plays a “24/7 elder care provider that is completely free, and also your sister.” Other men in the ad describe the benefits of having a sister care for aging parents.

Mulaney said:

“My dad means the world to me. So when I noticed him start to slow down, I knew I needed to get him the best care possible. I didn’t want to put him in a nursing home, but a private health aide could cost thousands a week. I didn’t know where to turn. That’s when I heard about Sister.”

The clip passed 2 million YouTube views after airing. Comments overwhelmingly agreed that the arrangement was “too real,” “so true” and “triggering.” Business Insider has covered long-term caregivers for the past year and is seeking payment data through a caregiver survey. Reporters also invited people caring for an elderly loved one to compare their spending with siblings.

How large is the care gap?

Waterlily, an AI-powered financial planning platform, combined its own data with Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services data and found that America’s family care system runs on daughters. Daughters were about twice as likely as sons to provide hands-on care, including help with dressing and bathing. Among providers, daughters typically spent more hours each week. Business Insider did not state Waterlily’s sample size.

Well over a dozen women caregivers told Business Insider they wanted their siblings, often men, to do more. Their parents had expected daughters to provide care so sons could focus on careers or families. Daughters managed finances and appointments; some quit jobs or became live-in caregivers.

Most caregivers refused to discuss siblings on the record. They feared sibling retaliation and did not want to make care appear burdensome, although they described it that way privately. Unpaid caregivers tend to be older. More than 11 million women elder care providers were 55 or older in the BLS data. Although women form the majority, many men are primary caregivers for aging parents.

What happens when the family plan fails?

Business Insider reported the case of Dina Mabry, whose grandmother lived alone in a mobile home until she poured boiling water on herself, then moved into skilled nursing care. Mabry’s mother became the primary caregiver because her two brothers could neither take her in nor help pay. The disagreement caused a rift that took years to heal.

Her parents had set aside thousands for retirement and travel, but $6,000 to $8,000 each month went to her mother’s six years in care facilities. The cost pushed their retirement back by years. Mabry, 58, works in long-term care and disability insurance.

Mabry’s advice, shaped by that experience, is to discuss care preferences with loved ones years before a crisis and set aside enough money for home-care nurses or assisted living. Her worst-case scenario is a daughter suddenly taking responsibility for full-time care.

What do care services cost?

Nursing-home and adult-day-service prices have risen faster than overall consumer prices since the 1990s and can reach six figures, Business Insider reported. AARP found that caregivers spend more than $11,000 per year out of pocket on average, including substantial household costs for food and housing. Business Insider gave no AARP sample size.

Sana Sheraz is the youngest of five siblings, yet caring for her aging parents mainly falls to her. She attributes that pattern to her earnings and financial stability, rather than having more free time, while balancing care for her parents and her children.

Medical costs and major decisions shift toward her through direct requests or unspoken expectations. She describes the pause after a cost is mentioned and the assumption that she can handle it.

How does care divide among siblings?

Angelina Grigoryeva, an associate professor of sociology at the University of Toronto, has studied how siblings divide elder care. She finds a financial and emotional cost, along with changes in women’s relationship to work. Women both provide and receive more care; parents may feel more comfortable with daughters for dressing, bathing and similar tasks.

Care work extends beyond daily assistance. Grigoryeva says siblings also organize paid care, find caregivers with whom their parents feel comfortable and pay for those services. Business Insider reported that 86% of home health aides and 87% of nursing assistants were women in 2025. It did not identify the underlying workforce denominator.

How does care become a second job?

Carla Romagnano, who is in her 60s, moved her mother, in her 80s and living with dementia, into her home. She calls caregiving the hardest job she has ever had. After work, she sits in her driveway to decompress before her second job begins.

Her second job covers her mother’s needs, her two border collies and the rest of the day. She describes it as two full-time jobs and says she would not wish it on anybody.

AARP Executive Vice President and Chief Public Policy Officer Debra Whitman said: “When working caregivers reduce their hours or need to quit their job entirely, they lose not only their current salary and benefits but also opportunities to save for retirement and build future Social Security benefits.” The statement makes caregiving a workforce issue, not only a private family matter.

Careb Bien-Aime worked as a home health aide for a few years while attending college because she wanted a flexible job. Her duties included helping clients walk and transferring them from beds. She found the work difficult and rewarding. During a permanent case lasting about a year, she built a relationship with her first client, who later died.

What should employers watch next?

For employers, the source leaves a concrete planning question: can work and benefits arrangements absorb demands that already push some workers to reduce hours or leave? The evidence reaches beyond family time. It reaches hours, income, benefits and retirement security, placing caregiving inside workforce planning rather than outside it.

Source: feeds.businessinsider.com

Share this article:

More from Nathan Brooks

Nathan Brooks

Show full bio

News editor covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in Recruiting and talent acquisition, learning and development at HR Briefing.

257 articles

© 2026 HR Briefing. All rights reserved.